Robinhood NFT
Marketplace

Duration
December 20, 2021 - January 3, 2022
Stakeholders
Robinhood
Kleiner Perkins
Team
Resham Khanna
Dimitri Knight
My Role
I took charge of product thinking and user experience design. I collaborated with Dimitri on competitor research and need finding, interviewing, and analysis of existing products. I created mobile interfaces and design components based on research findings that achieve our desired goals of security, education, and discoverability while being in line with Robinhood's current visual identity.
Skill
UX Design
UX Research
Visual Design
Product Thinking
Market Analysis
Crypto Research
Tools
Figma
Photoshop
After Effects

Overview

About

NFTs, or non-fungible tokens, are digital assets that represent real-world objects like art, music, in-game items, and videos. They are one of a kind and can be bought and sold online using cryptocurrency. Robinhood NFT Marketplace aims to be a peer-to-peer NFT marketplace that makes discovering, selling, buying, and learning about NFTs effortless and enjoyable through beginner-friendly designs.

Product Vision

Robinhood NFT Marketplace aims to bring down barriers for non-technical users to interact with blockchain technologies and explore new forms of investments with user-friendly and familiar interfaces. Our product vision aligns with Robinhood’s overarching mission statement to democratize finance for all and facilitate creator economies' expansion.

Make NFT investing user friendly and less intimidating

Context

Background

what's going on?

Non-fungible tokens play a crucial role in helping people achieve increased economic freedom by enabling creators and artists to explore novel ways of establishing creativity and ownership. Although they have been around for years, NFTs exploded in popularity in 2021, and their global market valuation reached a whopping $52 billion (according to crypto.com).

Problem

What needs fixing?

Even though NFTs investments are currently all the craze, the option to manage them with the same precision and as part of mobile apps that people already use to keep track of other investment instruments is still largely unavailable. Additionally, there are limited platforms that cater to non-crypto-savvy users who are less familiar with crypto jargon and processes.

Opportunity

where's the value?

Since Robinhood announced, it would be launching its crypto wallet in January 2021, introducing its own NFT marketplace would allow the company to enable users to manage all their investment assets in one place without having to leave the app to use third-party platforms like OpenSea. Robinhood's mobile brokerage expertise transfers well to creating a product that simplifies and democratizes NFT's.

How might we help investors confidently and effortlessly invest in NFTs on Robinhood ?

Research

Design Goal for Blockchain

setting standards

Blockchain's user experience issues need to be addressed. As is often with technology, jargon creates friction for the user experience and can lead to wasted funds and time, leaving new investors confused and frustrated. Experiencing high commission fees and slow transaction speed discourages investors from trading or using the platform often. Address names are unnecessarily complex and usually not customized by their holder.

Blockchain’s famed transparency is hardly usable for people unfamiliar with technology. Overall, the current state of blockchain causes it to be used by a small group of users, who are forced to deal with relatively high entry barriers and numerous questions and problems than meeting user needs. Keeping these pain points in mind, we came up with four key design goals to follow during this redesign process: Discoverability, Awareness, Education, and Security.

Discoverability

  • Enable users to explore newly added, featured, and trending creators and creations through a variety of filtering options
  • Ensure customizability of content on platform home feed, so the user is flexible in terms of what they value and want to see more of
  • Supporting users in finding more relevant items through a search by using item categories (e.g. art, music, 3D, etc.) and hashtags

Awareness

  • A concise breakdown of any fee (e.g. such as for gas) and/or commissions for trades on the platform
  • Clear communication about the security, usage, and public visibility of the investors’ personal information
  • Provide the most relevant information at first glance on cards for individual listing items and collections

Education

  • Education via tooltips and expandable options that explain jargon like “gas fees” and “wallet address”
  • Vetted articles and documentation from top Crypto organizations and content from Robinhood Learn can help people improve their technical understanding, making investors feel more confident
  • News section so investors can make informed decisions

Security

  • Multi-factor authentication in-app, so we know it's you when you initiate a transfer and transaction checks to understand better the risk of where coins are being sent.
  • Provide better protection against scams using interface features like the "report" button and the "verified profile" checkmarks for official accounts

Sentiment Analysis

We performed sentiment analysis to extract and identify emotions, attitudes, and opinions from our sample sets on Twitter, Quora, and YouTube.

Twitter

Our findings reflected that users, on the whole, expect Robinhood to have an NFT offering primarily because of Coinbase’s recent NFT marketplace announcement. Further, Robinhood is seen as a default brokerage for young, new investors, and the NFT market shares the same demographic appeal.

Quora

Several users have identified and codified the critical features of popular NFT players. It appears that at this point: there is a playbook for creating an active NFT marketplace. But, factors that differentiate marketplaces are simple, pleasing user interface/experience, and network effects with diverse artist offerings.

YouTube

We found several NFT money-making tutorials with hundreds of thousands to millions of views. Other popular video essays explain the NFT phenomena, the underlying technology, and the possible future.

Robinhood's Values & Vision

Democratize finance for all.

Friendly

Because of widely-covered industry fraud and scheming, the finance sector is seen as unfriendly and exclusionary. On the other hand, Robinhood’s products are widely known for being straightforward, usable, and friendly. Their memorable illustrations and bright color palette reflect a new, refreshing face for retail investing.

Approachable

Robinhood set an industry standard for commission-less trading paired with their simple, accessible mobile brokerage. Compared to other brokerage’s Robinhood prioritized the needs of retail traders instead of institutional traders. As a result, the average citizen has far fewer investment barriers and gets a high-quality investing education.

Understandable

There is a stark contrast between the user experience of legacy brokerages and Robinhood’s offerings. Because of Robinhood’s platform, new retail traders are no longer intimidated by complex charts, random numbers, and financial jargon that complicate the trading process. Instead, traders are given only the most vital information. Robinhood also offers in-depth courses through its education section.

Shareable

A significant contributor to Robinhood’s virality has been the sharability of Robinhood’s simple, understandable interface. Robinhood’s interfaces have made it easy to share your investment journey with others on the internet. Traders on Reddit would famously share their Robinhood portfolio to share the explicit story of their historical P/L.

Robinhood Crypto COO Quote

Statement on NFT's future

“So here's what I love about NFTs. Today, the number of 18- to 29-year-olds who are actively investing, right, who have any investment, is less than 30%. So investing has a whole lot of barriers to entry, whether it's economic, educational, emotional. NFTs bring that barrier down a little bit more, right? We've all hung something on the wall. We've all put something on a refrigerator.”

“...the jump from, hey, art, music, things that are real and let's make that digital is a lot easier than investing, which the majority of young individuals today aren't doing and saying, OK now, there's a digital component to this, right? The jump is just a little bit easier.”

“...we'd be silly to not be looking at right now.”

— Christine Brown, as told to Yahoo! Finance

Market Statistics

Data provided by NFTGO.com

NFTs made headlines in 2021 due to the increasing number of sales, particularly the sales of Beeple's "Everyday: the First 5000 Days", which became the world's most expensive NFT. Since then, NFT sales volume skyrocketed, with the market cap reaching a total of over 11.5 billion U.S. dollars as of the latest data, according to NFTGO.com.

  • Education via tooltips and expandable options that explain jargon like “gas fees” and “wallet address”
  • Vetted articles and documentation from top Crypto organizations and content from Robinhood Learn can help people improve their technical understanding, making investors feel more confident
  • News section so investors can make informed decisions

Competitive Analysis

Who are the top players?

OpenSea is the leader in NFT sales. It is the world’s most prominent marketplace for Crypto collectibles. It also supports artists and creators and has an easy-to-use process if you want to mint your own NFT. The marketplace supports more than 150 different payment tokens. OpenSea says it is now worth $13.3bn following a new investment of $300mm.

Why are they on top?

OpenSea has all sorts of digital assets available on its platform, and it's free to sign up and browse the extensive offerings.  They also sport a fully customizable landing page/marketplace. Users also only pay minting and listing fees once and can mint the rest for free.

Top Marketplaces

Competitive Analysis
Data provided by Kyros Ventures

Marketplace Rankings & Analysis

Competitive Analysis
Data provided by Dapprader

A Closer Look

Competitive Analysis

Coinbase plans to open its own NFT marketplace, where people will be able to trade digital art and other items in the next quarter or two. The company wants to offer a one-stop experience for users to make purchases and store their holdings on a platform. Their platform would provide a social media experience more similar to Instagram than a traditional marketplace like eBay Inc. Coinbase has received more than 2.5 million emails seeking to sign up for the marketplace since it was first announced in October.

The biggest existing NFT marketplace, OpenSea, had about 236,000 unique user addresses interacting with it in the last 30 days, according to data tracker DappRadar. Coinbase is an investor in OpenSea.
Users will showcase their NFTs on the Coinbase site and let others follow their profile and receive updates. Such features could be vital to getting the word out and attracting users when many social networks are also jumping into the NFT market.

Marketplace Rankings & Analysis

Competitive Analysis
Data provided by Messari

Interviews

Research methodology

We conducted five individual interviews with users aged 21-25, ranging from avid to new NFT investors. We recruited people to interview based on varying backgrounds and expertise levels. While our focus remained on learning more about their needs, goals, and pain points about the NFT investing process, their diverse perspectives contributed to different types of insights.

Goal

Understand how users currently interact with and invest in NFTs to derive insights on how Robinhood could build a platform that better supports the needs of various stakeholders in the system.

Personas

Research methodology

Our personas were inspired by our anonymous interviewees, their key insights, and personal stories. We share their background, motivations, pain points, NFT and investing background, and goals.

Biography

Annie recently graduated from college and now works as a designer. She’s passionate about her career and wants to progress. But, she is often bored at work and struggles to save money. In 2020, she heard more about cryptocurrency and began researching NFT’s as an alternative investment. She currently holds bitcoin and ethereum on Robinhood Crypto platform and also uses the Robinhood app for stocks.

Goals

  • Would like to manage her NFT investments in the same place as her crypto and stalks, i.e., within the Robinhood app
  • She’d like to learn more about NFT’s because she is an art enthusiast and potentially invest in some pieces on a simple, trustworthy platform

Needs

  • She needs to know that her holdings are safe are accessible from hackers and scammers.
  • It wasn’t easy to understand when she began her research. As an investor, she needs an app that is simple to understand.

Pain Points

  • After hearing about many wallet holders losing access, she’s worried about scams and hackers or simply forgetting her login.

Biography

Amay has been an artist his entire life and avidly follows new technology. In 2015, he became fascinated by blockchain and cryptocurrency. He first bought Bitcoin and Ethereum and then branched out to many other tokens. He became interested because of ideological beliefs but has since made a lot of money through his NFT collections. He is optimistic about the future of NFT’s and would like to share his art with as many people as possible.

Goals

  • Initially, it was hard for Amay to get discovered. Now, he wants to continue competing with other creators by auctioning his work
  • Maximizing the likelihood of higher bids by reaching a large audience while engaging with platforms that have the cheapest fees

Needs

  • A platform with an easy interface and straightforward process for minting, tracking auctions, processing sales, and viewing sale data
  • Climbing ranks as a top NFT creator to get their work more recognition; prefers working on investors purchases over client work

Pain Points

  • Worried about discoverability as he creates a particular type of art and because new NFT creators are flooding the market
  • He does not enjoy client work as it requires him to operate under stricter constraints and has yielded lower profits than certain investors sales

Biography

Abbey works at a management consulting firm and likes investing in NFTs as a self-proclaimed ‘side hustle.’ She has been involved in the NFT space since 2019 and is surprised by the industry’s recent explosion in popularity. In 2021, a scammer sold her a fake version of a popular NFT which made her lose a significant amount of money. However, she wants to work on regaining her confidence and continue investing.

Goals

  • Wants to invest in NFTs with greater confidence after being scammed on OpenSea despite being well-versed with crypto
  • Having the option to curate the content she wants to discover and explore, as she wants to invest in NFTs by emerging creators

Needs

  • Abbey would like to build a diverse, potentially high-yielding portfolio
  • More safeguards prevent herself from getting scammed again and features that help identify the legitimacy of accounts and items

Pain Points

  • Wary and distrustful after having a bad experience with NFTs, she does not want to risk losing more funds to very convincing scams
  • Worried about the exclusion of individuals lacking technical know-how from NFT investing due to lack of easy to understand platforms
What were the main takeaways?
Figure 2: Mindmap of extensive contextual analysis from driver’s perspective

Key Insights

Research summary & Synthesis

We used affinity diagramming to derive critical insights from our interviews and literature review. We found themes in four primary areas: Customization, Trust & Security, Simplicity, and Education.

These themes inspired primary features for the new NFT marketplace and served as selling points for the NFT marketplace.

Features

Education

Inspire informed action

Empower investors to make informed decisions by providing them with vetted information and news

Simplify intimidating topics

Utilize Robinhood Learn to help people process technically challenging topics more easily

Abstract, but still teach

Balance jargon and abstract away details, so new users are motivated to learn but aren’t overwhelmed

Customization

Improve the exploration process

Allow users to customize the content they want to see on their home page and explore feed

Help creators get traction

Facilitate the discovery of emerging creators by creating categories for new artists on the platform

Provide granular search options

Provide a search bar, content categories, filters, and hashtags that improve searchability

Moodboards

Organize content, your way

Schemas vary based on experience and perspective. Users can express themselves by creating and sharing moodboards with the community.

Browse similar recommendations

Similar to how Spotify recommends songs to your playlist based on past listens, the marketplace shows you what you’d love based on your moodboards.

Share your perspective

Community is a key pillar of the NFT ecosystem. Being a part of it, you see the world differently from others, and your moodboards would reflect that.

Security

Multi-factor Authentication

Include multi-factor authentication before in-app transactions like placing bids on items

Report suspicious listings

Visual elements like profile checkmarks and report buttons generate more trust from users

Manage your personal details

Keep traders in the know about their information’s visibility and usage

Cards

Glanceable

There’s only so much time in a day. With glanceable cards, you can gather only the most necessary information.

Appealing

NFTs can reveal the artist and appreciators in all of us. Cards let the art speak for itself, with as few distractions as possible.

Balanced

We display only two cards per row to give each item the focus it deserves, avoid cognitive overload, and yet show multiple listings as you scroll

Flows

Reflection

How did I feel when working on the design challenge?

This project is special because this product could potentially help people feel less intimidated and more confident about entering the world of crypto. Bringing down barriers to entry and increasing access are things I personally care a lot about, given my upbringing and the lack of resources I experienced. There were days where we felt overwhelmed, but I’m proud of everything we managed to do.

What would I have done differently?

We only designed the user-facing side, but I would’ve loved to explore what the platform might’ve looked like for creators. With more time, it would be worthwhile designing flows to create, mint, manage auctions, track sales, etc. I would’ve also explored more ways to gamify crypto education and gone through a few cycles of user testing and redesigns based on the findings.

What did we learn about each other from this project?

My respect for Dimitri’s design skills only continues to grow after every collaborative project. He is exceptionally determined and worked on this despite having COVID. Watching him get physically repulsed by bad visuals is amusing but is proof of how deeply he cares about design. It is inspiring to watch him design, even when parts of his process include scrolling through Twitter and spinning in his swivel chair.

What did I learn about myself from this project?

I hadn’t designed on Figma in some time as I’d been more involved with game engines at my previous internship. This project made me more confident in my visual and UX skills because I am able to  clearly recognize, perhaps for the first time, how far I’ve come from where I’ve started.  Working on this case study also taught me to not be afraid to think big, and to continue combining different things I care about — which was my love for creator economies, art, crypto, and design, in this case.